Extra work

Change order vs. construction change directive under AIA A201

Under AIA A201–2017, a change order records agreement on the work and any price or time adjustment, with owner, contractor and architect signatures. A construction change directive is signed by the owner and architect and can direct a change within the contract’s general scope before total agreement on the adjustment.

The difference at a glance

QuestionChange orderConstruction change directive
A201 reference§7.2.1§§7.3.1–7.3.2
Who prepares it?ArchitectArchitect
Who signs to issue it?Owner, contractor, architectOwner and architect
Are the adjustments agreed?Yes: work, sum and timeNot necessarily all terms
Typical AIA formG701–2017G714–2017
Must work proceed?Promptly, unless the instrument says otherwise (§7.1.3)Promptly, with response on adjustment method (§7.3.6)

A directive is not unlimited authority

AIA §7.3.1 describes changes within the general scope of the contract. It is not a blanket right to demand any work imaginable. A directive also needs the contractual authority and execution required by the documents. An informal message from someone without authority is not automatically the instrument described in Article 7.

A subcontractor should examine how the prime contract provisions flow down and what the subcontract says about GC directions, notice and compensation. The owner–contractor A201 procedure is not automatically the exact GC–subcontractor procedure. This guide refers to the unmodified A201–2017, not every construction contract.

Proceed, respond and document are separate tasks

Under §7.3.6, receipt of a construction change directive calls for prompt performance and advice to the architect about agreement or disagreement with the method proposed for determining the contract-sum or time adjustment. A blanket “never start without a signed change order” policy misses this requirement.

Keep a contemporaneous record of the work, resources, instructions and schedule effects. Where terms remain disputed, use the applicable notice procedure. A field diary is helpful evidence, but it does not by itself satisfy every notice obligation. For a disputed direction or scope boundary, involve the appropriate commercial and legal reviewer promptly.

A directive does not always mean T&M

AIA §7.3.3 provides several ways to determine the price adjustment: a supported lump sum, stated or agreed unit prices, an agreed cost method with a mutually acceptable fee, or the §7.3.4 process. Choose and document the method required or agreed for the actual directive.

Where §7.3.4 applies, the architect determines the adjustment based on reasonable attributable expenditures or savings and the specified overhead/profit treatment. The contractor must keep itemized accounting with appropriate supporting data. Contract documents can alter the allowed categories and treatment. Daily T&M tickets may support that accounting, but they are not the whole pricing agreement.

A contractor signature on a CCD is not merely receipt

AIA §7.3.7 expressly says a contractor’s signature indicates agreement, including the sum and time adjustments or the method for determining them. The agreement is immediately effective and is recorded as a change order. Read the instrument before signing; do not describe this contractual signature as only acknowledging that a document arrived.

That is different from a field ticket expressly limited to acknowledgment of observed hours or quantities. Even for a ticket, the effect depends on wording, authority, the contract and circumstances. There is no universal rule that all signatures either approve payment or have no commercial effect.

Payment need not wait for every term to be finalized

Under §7.3.9, completed directive work can be included in payment applications pending final cost determination. The architect makes an interim determination for monthly certification, subject to the Article 15 process. Do not assume all directive work is unpaid until a final change order exists.

Under §7.3.10, agreed adjustments become effective immediately and the architect prepares a change order. That change order may address all or part of the directive. Reconcile what has been agreed, what was certified and what remains unresolved so neither the change log nor the billing record double-counts the work.

Do not confuse a CCD with a minor change

AIA §7.4 concerns written minor changes consistent with the contract’s intent that do not adjust the contract sum or extend contract time. If the contractor believes the proposed minor change affects sum or time, the clause requires notice to the architect and says not to implement it. Performing without prior impact notice waives the adjustment or extension described there.

That differs from the prompt-performance requirement for a CCD. Identify which mechanism is actually being used rather than treating every written instruction as interchangeable. Keep the source instruction and the applicable clause beside the field record.

Use the project brain to organize, not decide entitlement

Magra can bring together the directive, contract reference, schedule, crew updates and photos from that project. It can ask about missing facts and prepare a document draft for your approval. It should not declare that an instruction is legally valid or that a disputed cost is automatically payable.

Use source-linked project information to make the review faster. Verify the executed contract, amendments, sender authority and notice requirements before acting on a commercial conclusion.

Common questions

Does the contractor have to sign a CCD before it is issued?

Under unmodified AIA A201–2017, the CCD is prepared by the architect and signed by the owner and architect. Contractor assent is not required to issue it.

Is a CCD always priced on time and materials?

No. AIA §7.3.3 allows multiple pricing methods, including supported lump sum and agreed unit prices.

Can a CCD become more than one change order?

AIA §7.3.10 allows a change order to address all or part of a directive as adjustments are agreed.

Sources & editorial note

By Magra editorial. Examples are illustrative, not customer results. Not legal advice; executed documents, amendments and applicable law govern. Product availability can change.

Put the record to work.

Magra is the AI project manager for contractors, on your phone.

Explore source-linked contract context · Text Magra

Keep reading